Isn't it cool that, perhaps for the first time in their lives, the people of my community can possess their own family portraits?
The gift of a photograph is just another token that, in a couple of years will just be another piece of trash in the patio.
The thought that I might be providing a valuable service or a priceless experience is not a convincing argument. The good/fun that comes from this does not convince me that I'm doing the right thing:
* I'm fueling the belief that all gringos carry cameras
* I'm supporting the assumption that I can easily travel in and out of the community, to and from the city (David, in this case) anytime to satisfy the priority of developing people’s photos
* I'm fulfilling the tourist destiny of photographing spectacles
- this puts me in the position as spectator and my neighbors as the objects, whether they know it or not, I don't feel comfortable with this: Am I here visiting some kind of museum or zoo?
* I'm taking their 50¢ or their $3 - yes this is a fair price, but they can't buy enough rice to feed everyone in the family. Despite the fact that I shouldn't put myself in a position to decide how my neighbors work out their personal finances, I don't like the fact that I'm providing the frivolous temptation to them.
* Young children might have "pena" about answering: Hola, but will yell requests to me:
"¿Saca mi foto?"
* Families I've never met or visited in their homes are asking my to stop by with my camera.
"Buenos días. ¿Cómo está?"
"¿Yo? Estoy aquí gracias a Dios."
"Va pa la escuela?"
"Si. ¿Tiene una camera?"
"Aah, pues, sí. Pero estoy caminando también, la camera está allá, en mi casa."
"Aah, así es. ¿Saca mi foto?"
"No tengo la camera, estoy viajando ahorita."
Maybe the expectation isn't really to take the photo RIGHT NOW, but instead of passing a stranger on the road and exchanging greetings and learning who's neighbor of who's cousin I'm talking to, I'm being asked: "¿Saca mi foto?"
*This provides many opportunities to visit/pasear with new people.
*...
But it's hard to see the bright side of this. I am the first PC Volunteer to work in my community and one of my legacies will automatically be: Ella tuvo una camera.
No comments:
Post a Comment